Everyday Scientist

experimenting with preprints

May 9, 2016 at 12:15 pm | sam | literature, science community

We recently uploaded a preprint to bioRxiv. The goal was to hopefully get some constructive feedback to improve the manuscript. So far, it got some tweets and even an email from a journal editor, but no comments or constructive feedback.

I notice that very few preprints on bioRxiv have any comments at all. Of course, scientists may be emailing each other privately about papers on bioRxiv, and that would be great. But I think a open process would be valuable. F1000Research, for example, has a totally open review process, posting the referee reports right with the article. I might be interested in trying that journal someday.

UPDATE: In the end, we did receive a couple emails from students who had read the preprint for their journal club. They provided some nice feedback. Super nice! We also received some helpful feedback on another preprint, and we updated the manuscript before submitting to a journal. Preprints can be super useful for pre-peer review.